Nepal's National Psyché Sees India to the North

>> Sunday, December 27, 2009

By Ajay Pradhan | December 27, 2009

"The whole aim of practical politics is to keep the populace alarmed--and hence clamorous to be led to safety--by menacing it with an endless series of hobgoblins, all of them imaginary." -- H.L. Mencken
Mencken, the celebrated American essayist, journalist, satirist and acerbic critic of American life and culture, who died in 1956 at the age of 75, likely had a premonition about Nepal's current politicians when he wrote the above quote.

Nepal's contemporary politics is fast becoming a fairy tale of nightmare. Everyone has a tale to tell. In every tale, the hobgoblin is the country's southern neighbor that often creates trouble for Nepal.

For every trouble in every tale, our index finger automatically points to India--as though India is to our north and our index finger is the compass needle.

India is our southern neighbor and friend that we can't live without. But it is also a neighbor we love to hate with passion.

Such is the image of India, permanently etched in our national psyché--an image of a friendly but troublesome creature, just like the hobgoblins in the Seelie court of popular folktales. Such is our indelible national psyché.

Our fairytale political "leaders" from every political Seelie courts (read: political parties of every stripe and color) have done everything possible to create this national psyché. The purpose is simple. It is to keep the populace alarmed about a perceived threat from India, keep it clamorous for being shielded from the mostly imaginary threat.

I say imaginary, not because there is no threat at all, but because the significance of internal threat that ignites within Nepal is potentially more lethal for Nepal's integrity than of external threat from India that does exist.

It is the Nepali political leaders that mortgage the country's dignity and run to New Delhi whenever the going gets tough for them. Providing dignified leadership has become all but a big farce. There is no leadership to speak of. There is a vacuum of leadership.

Why else are the politicians treating the Constituent Assembly, which we had to wait for nearly 60 long years to get after first promised by King Tribhuvan, being treated as though it were merely a regular legislature?

It's too bad that the political leaders were too shortsighted to saddle the CA with the twin burden of governing and re-writing a new Constitution, when the CA should have been elected with the sole mandate of writing the Constitution, leaving the task of governing the country for a separate, interim political mechanism. It is worse that the politicians and the purveyors of democracy and people's interest are shackling the feet of the CA and preventing it from moving forward.

The lack of political vision, statesmanship, pragmatic strategy, and perpetual ineptness in governing and apathy for common concerns can only be hidden from people's eyes by baiting common Nepalis on a perceived threat from India. This is the purpose why the inept political leaders who have ruled Nepal throw wool in the eyes of the common citizens by blaming India for Nepal's every foible. By doing so, they each must share the blame for surrendering country's dignity and accepting India as their master.

And, what do we, the people, do about this? Do we show outrage towards our inept politicians who have hidden agenda? No. We do nothing to keep our leaders accountable.

Instead, we let our index finger automatically point towards India, when we should be pointing it to our own leaders within Nepal.


Chari December 28, 2009 at 3:16 AM  

i thought i was in for a fresh perspective wid mah cup of coffee.:)
well for now
would do jus fine to ponder upon and again gaze in the dark and NOT point nor seek the compass , jus gaze n build castles in the ImaGinaRy skY as we hab been doin all along.... sippin a cup of coffee ... ani tyai "swarnim nepal ko kalpana"...bikar rahit ...

Puru December 28, 2009 at 3:07 PM  

Helo Ajayaji,

Thanks for your introspection on Nepalese political psyche and bold remark with respect to our age old mixed approach to India, a regional superpower. Pro or anti -Indian sentiment in Nepal is a well tell tale truth.

Your blog made me recalled a relevant cartoon,published in SPotlight, in which Girija, the pro-India, longest serving PM, was acclaiming common people that "Nepal is in danger" and as a corollary, people were finger pointing "Girija is in danger!"

Another excerpt from a book "real fight for democracy of Nepal was not fought not in Nepal but within four walls of Delhi palace" also hold relevance in terms of ineffective indigenous Nepalese political leadership.

Evidently, there is no dearth of rational public voicing and "dare to dream" for an an efficient Nepalese politico-administrative set up and a strengthened GDP growth. But there exist laxity of strong political will. It is a matter of waiting for a great leader.

A fitting analogy can be emergence of Barrack Obama in the USA, as reportedly, Martin Luther King had publicly outcried " Lord, give us a great leader" to correct the dismal future.

About This Blog

Humanature Journal blog is maintained by A.S. Pradhan.


Opinions expressed on this blog are personal opinions of the writers, not of the organizations they are associated with.

  © Blogger templates Shiny by 2008

Back to TOP