Pointing Fingers at Wrong Direction

>> Sunday, May 3, 2015

Published in The Republica (Nepal's broadsheet daily newspaper), January 20, 2010.


Pointing fingers at wrong direction
“The whole aim of practical politics is to keep the populace alarmed—and hence clamorous to be led to safety—by menacing it with an endless series of hobgoblins, all of them imaginary.” - HL Mencken

When Mencken, the celebrated American essayist, journalist, satirist and acerbic critic of American life and culture, who died in 1956 at the age of 75, wrote the above quote, it seems as if he had a premonition about Nepal’s current politicians.

Nepal’s contemporary politics is fast becoming a fairy tale of nightmare. Everyone has a tale to tell. In every tale, the hobgoblin is the country’s southern neighbor that often creates trouble for Nepal.

For every trouble in every tale, many of ours index fingers seem to be automatically pointing towards India—as though India is to our north and our index finger is the compass needle.

India is our southern neighbor and friend that we can’t live without. However, it is also a neighbor, at times, we love to hate with passion.

Such seems to be the image of India, permanently etched in our national psyche—an image of a friendly but troublesome creature, just like the hobgoblins in the Seelie court of popular folktales. Such seems to be our indelible national psyché.

It is the Nepali political leaders who mortgage the country’s dignity and run to New Delhi whenever the going gets tough.
Our fairytale political ‘leaders’ from every political Seelie courts i.e. political parties of every stripe and color have done everything possible to create this national psyché. The purpose is simple. It is to keep the populace alarmed about a perceived threat from India and to keep it in unreasonable fear for being shielded from the mostly imaginary threat.

say imaginary, not because there is no threat at all, but because the significance of internal threat that ignites within Nepal is potentially more lethal for Nepal’s integrity than of external threat from India.

It is the Nepali political leaders who mortgage the country’s dignity and run to New Delhi whenever the going gets tough for them. Seemingly, dignified leadership has become all but a big farce. There is no leadership to speak of. There is a vacuum of leadership.

Why else are the politicians treating the Constituent Assembly (CA), which we had to wait for nearly 60 long years to get after it was first promised by King Tribhuvan, as though it were merely a regular legislature?

It is too bad that the political leaders were too shortsighted to saddle the CA with the twin burden of governing and re-writing a new constitution, when the CA should have been elected with the sole mandate of writing the constitution, leaving the task of governing the country for a separate, interim political mechanism. It is worse that the politicians and the purveyors of democracy and people’s interest are shackling the feet of the CA and preventing it from moving forward.

The lack of political vision, statesmanship, pragmatic strategy, and perpetual ineptness in governing and apathy for common concerns can only be hidden from people’s eyes by baiting common Nepalis on a perceived threat from India. This is the purpose why the inept political leaders who have ruled Nepal throw dust in the eyes of the common citizens by blaming India for Nepal’s every foible. By doing so, they each must share the blame for surrendering country’s dignity and accepting India as their master.

And, what do we, the people, do about this? Do we show outrage towards our inept politicians who have hidden agenda? No. We do nothing to make our leaders accountable.

Instead, we allow our index fingers automatically point towards India, when we should be pointing them to our own leaders in Nepal.

  Published on 2010-01-20 00:30:05


writer is absolutely correct. we the people are being misinformed and led astray by our very own elected leaders and it is a sad thing. we the people ca only elect them but we should also have the power to boot them out if they become a nuisance. blame game doesnot benefit any body and only positive action on the part of people can set things right.[more]
- ykbhattarai
It is amazing how the author of this article is pointing fingers at a wrong direction himself. it is not the leaders that are to be blamed for the political chaos that surrounds the country right now. truth be told the Nepalese populous lacks political literacy, it lacks a will for progress and development, and finally it lacks a vision for a better Nepal. however we are really efficient like the author of this article at pointing fingers towards others. It is we, who are to be blamed because fo [more]
- Aman makaju
Ajaya Ji: Nice to see your analytical, short and sweet article. It has been a dilemma that after our leaders fail in governance, they blame others for own failure. Earlier it was a trend to blame to the royal palace, then the trend descends down at the party level and now to India. Though no political party is fair, some political party likes to land rockets on others´ foreheads. If its political cadre kills someone, this party constitutes a commission and concludes something funny. No[more]
- K. Bhujel


Anonymous May 20, 2019 at 4:57 AM  

Hello there! This article could not be written much better!
Going through this article reminds me of my previous roommate!
He constantly kept talking about this. I most certainly will send this post
to him. Pretty sure he's going to have a great read.
I appreciate you for sharing!

About This Blog

Humanature Journal blog is maintained by A.S. Pradhan.


Opinions expressed on this blog are personal opinions of the writers, not of the organizations they are associated with.

  © Blogger templates Shiny by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP